Decide Denies Connecticut Man His Murdered Spouse’s Life Insurance coverage Coverage


A federal courtroom choose has dominated that an insurance coverage firm doesn’t should pay an East Haddam man the $257,000 insurance coverage coverage belonging to his murdered spouse though nobody has been charged in her 2018 dying.

Decide Victor Bolden lately ordered the Zurich American Life Insurance coverage Firm to put Sandra Kalosky’s insurance coverage profit into an escrow account quite than pay it to her husband Robert Kalosky. Bolden stated for the reason that March 2018 murder is unsolved the insurance coverage firm is in an untenable place.

“If Zurich paid the advantages to Mr. Kalosky, after which Mr. Kalosky was then discovered to be disqualified, Zurich could face a declare from Ms. Kalosky’s step-son or sisters,” Bolden wrote. “Alternatively if Zurich paid the advantages to Ms. Kalosky’s step-son or sisters, and the homicide subsequently was solved in a way that made it extra possible then not Mr. Kalosky wasn’t the assassin, Zurich would face a declare from Mr. Kalosky.”

Sandra Kalosky, 56, was discovered crushed to dying in her dwelling on North Moodus Street on March 23, 2018. State police have stated little about her dying aside from that she died of blunt trauma to the top and her dying has been dominated a murder. Nobody has been arrested.

Robert Kalosky, who’s 67, filed a declare for his spouse’s life insurance coverage profit 5 days after the homicide. He’s listed as the only beneficiary of her coverage, which was taken out in 2011.

Reasonably than pay the declare the insurance coverage firm filed a federal lawsuit a yr after her homicide as a result of it didn’t need to pay the husband in case he was ever charged together with her homicide. Sandra was Kalosky’s second spouse to die below suspicious circumstances.

Kalosky has not responded to the lawsuit and has ignored a number of courtroom dates. Bolden has granted a default movement towards Kalosky for failing to reply to the lawsuit. Kalosky hasn’t commented on his spouse’s dying aside from a now-removed Fb put up that thanked his “actual associates” for standing by him following the homicide.

Bolden has ordered Zurich to show the cash over to the U.S. District Court docket Clerk to be put into an escrow account till or whether it is ever decided who killed Sandra Kalosky and who the beneficiary ought to be. The corporate’s lawyer’s made it clear it didn’t need to pay Kalosky within the preliminary submitting.

“Inasmuch because the murder dying of the deceased stays open and unsolved, [Zurich] can not decide whether or not a courtroom would discover that Robert Kalosky is and/or could also be disqualified from receiving the plan advantages based mostly on federal widespread legislation and/or Connecticut state legislation that prohibits a person from receiving funds if that individual is convicted within the dying of the deceased,” stated Regen O’Malley, a lawyer for [Zurich], in a courtroom submitting.

If a federal choose have been to ultimately rule that Robert Kalosky isn’t eligible to obtain the dying profit then both his son, Phillip T. Kalosky, or Sandra Kalosky’s surviving sisters, Barbara Kaluza or Janet Guerrini, might be beneficiaries.

Sandra Kalosky is the second spouse of Robert Kalosky’s who has died below violent circumstances in the identical home.

Practically 20 years in the past, Paula Kalosky was discovered with a single gunshot wound to the top in the identical dwelling. The dying was initially dominated a suicide however modified to “undetermined, ” in 2004. Robert Kalosky has not been charged nor named as a suspect in both dying.

The change within the 2004 case got here after John Carbo, Paula Kalosky’s brother, filed a wrongful dying lawsuit towards Robert Kalosky.

The lawsuit was settled for about $95,000 simply earlier than proof was to start out earlier than a jury. The vast majority of the settlement, $53,000, was positioned into a school fund for the couple’s son, who ultimately went to Johnson & Wales College.

In accordance with the wrongful-death lawsuit, the 2 girls knew one another and Sandra divorced her husband and moved in with Robert Kalosky a couple of yr after Paula Kalosky’s dying.

In his assertion to state police after Paula Kalosky’s physique was discovered, a duplicate of which is in Carbo’s possession, Robert Kalosky stated he did not hear any gunshots that morning. He instructed police he left the home and went to withdraw cash from an ATM and to get fuel. After coming dwelling and beginning breakfast, he went to test on his spouse and located her useless together with his gun subsequent to her.

Robert Kalosky stated he known as 911, then moved the gun on the behest of the dispatcher earlier than going exterior to attend for emergency personnel. Kalosky instructed police that Paula had been upset by the dying of her mom from most cancers about 5 months earlier.

Carbo stated his sister, who labored for a Hartford insurance coverage firm, was about to graduate from the College of Hartford and had picked out her commencement robe just a few days earlier than her dying.

After the suicide ruling, the household employed Michael Malchick, a former state police detective, to evaluation the case. The state police reopened the case and the style of dying was modified to “undetermined, ” in accordance with the wrongful dying go well with and medical expert’s workplace.


(c)2019 The Hartford Courant (Hartford, Conn.)

Go to The Hartford Courant (Hartford, Conn.) at

Distributed by Tribune Content material Company, LLC.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here